5 Reasons Why Midsommar Is One Of The Worst Horror Movies Of 2019 (& 5 Why Its One Of The Best) – Screen Rant

Midsommar proved to be one of the most polarizing horror movies of 2019 and film fans are still debating whether it's one of the year's best or worst.

Writer and director Ari Aster's prompt followup to his hugely successfulfirst feature-length movie,Hereditary, proved somewhat more divisive than his debut and still inspires debate amongst horror movie fans, and general audience members, as to whether it does or doesn't deserve its still very high level of critical acclaim.

RELATED:10 Horror Movies from the 2010s That Critics Loved (But Audiences Hated)

The numerous conflicting opinions can be very confusing to newcomers to the movie. So, with this in mind, let's break down the arguments for and against the movie being worthy of its modern classic status to try and better determine whetherMidsommarreally is as good, or bad, as some people say that it is.

Midsommaris always trying to be quite the trip and it often succeeds via a number of deliberately disorientating tactics and insidious frights lurking in the background.

The character's descent into drug-induced hysteria is helped greatly along by tiny details like pupil dilation and more subtle flashes of horrific imagery give the movie an unsettling atmosphere.

With so many triumphs in execution,Midsommarshould logically be a certified home run with horror movie fans but the plot has as many tired tropes and clichs propping it up as it does innovative ideas.

RELATED:10 Great Modern Horror Movies That You've Probably Never Heard Of

Conventional characterization within the movie is a subject within itself, which we'll get to later, but the hackneyed structure alone is enough to give a genre fan a headache. No self-respecting horror aficionado was surprised when the movie's only non-white couple was the first to die and it's disappointing, to say the least, every time it happens.

Ari Aster reteamed withHereditary's director of photography,Pawel Pogorzelski, onMidsommarand the two maintained the high standard that their debut together set.

The relatively limited environment is never dull to look at andPogorzelski demonstrates a clear eye for beauty in the natural landscapes of the movie.

So many of the movie's finer points simply aren't enjoyable in any way for certainpeople becausethey come off as unnecessarily weighty and pretentious.

RELATED:10 Low Budget Horror Movies That Are Better Than Blockbusters (& Where To Stream Them)

The real damning quality of this is thatMidsommaris always a genre movie yet often comes off as being ashamed to be identified as such, finding ways totrickthe audience into thinking that it has a level of complexity and importance that transcends its conventional gore and stereotypes.

Similar toHereditary,Midsommaris constantly mindful of ways that it can make its outlandish story seem grounded in a relatably real world.

Practical effects and smart set building go a long way in bringing the nightmarish qualities inMidosommarto life in an impactful way.

So much ofMidsommar's realism feels pointless when factoring it against the unbelievable nature of the story.

RELATED:10 Folk Horror Films To See If You Loved Midsommar

A staple ofunoriginal horror screenplays is characters who seem to have absolutely no regard for their own safety and it's a convenient trope that the movie's characters stick to even after watching a gruesome murder happen right in front of them.

Midsommar's story grapples with a number of mental health issues that the movie takes seriously and explores through events in the plot.

Chronic depression, trauma, emotional dependency, abusiveness, and communal support aretouched on by the story and the relationships between the characters.

While irritating main characters are no strangers to the horror genre, particularly within the types of horror movies thatMidsommarso clearly emulates, the basic fact remains that it's much easier to write annoying characters than it is to write likable ones.

RELATED:5 Things Midsommar Did Better Than Hereditary (& 5 Things Hereditary Did Better)

The movie's inconsideratestudents frequently stray beyond examinations of toxicity and into the realm of convenient jerks who the audience can root for thegrisly death of.

Though many of the characters may be run of the mill, theacting is far from it with even the most one-dimensional characters have impressive performances devoted to them.

Florance Pugh's central performance, obviously, takes the most praise from critics and fans alike but the entire ensemble never appears anything other than totally committed to the script, no matter how ridiculous the scenario may be.

So many ofMidosommar's detractors site the length as a key grievance that they have with the movie and it's not an invalid thing to point out.

The morbidity of the slasher movie is atoned for in the eyes of fans due to the fact that the subgenre embraces its place as entertainment.Midsommar, however, possesses an epicrunning time befitting a movie with far more intricate ideas and characters. A fact that isn't helped by the movie's repetitive insistence ofmapping out events in its own plot beforethey happen.

NEXT:10 Slasher Movies With Low Rotten Tomatoes Scores That Are Actually Classics

Next Harry Potter: 10 Ways Hermione Got Worse & Worse

Mark is a freelance copywriter and copyeditor. When not writing or editing, he can most likely be found complaining about movies on Twitter.

More:
5 Reasons Why Midsommar Is One Of The Worst Horror Movies Of 2019 (& 5 Why Its One Of The Best) - Screen Rant

Reviewed and Recommended by Erik Baquero