I dont care about the box office. I care about the connection. I want it to be a phenomenon a cultural phenomenon, where the audience feels some connection to this place, these people, and what was being said here. Thats Jaws, E.T, The Exorcist. All those movies. They just connected.
With this one small excerpt from a Newsweek interview with M. Night Shyamalan in 2002, anybody who initially couldnt understand the unconventional appeal of the then-white hot director got a nice dose of his philosophy. Conducted right around the time that Shyamalans Mel Gibson-starring sci-fi drama, Signs, was about to release, the interview provides an in-depth look at a filmmaker who many considered to be at the top of his game during this period.
His previous film, Unbreakable, didnt make a killing at the box office, but it was already well on its way to the cult status it still enjoys today. The film before that, a little supernatural thriller called The Sixth Sense, became arguably THE breakout hit of 1999, establishing the young upstart as one of the leaders of the new wave of cinema heading into a new millennium. Whether or not its what he wanted for himself, the power of heightened expectations dictated it.
The Sixth Sense
Its through those expectations that audiences have framed Nights peculiar career from humble beginnings to mainstream stardom and well into what is considered one of the most infamous streaks of films for any filmmaker. Shyamalans post-Signs filmography has been unceremoniously affected by the mixed-to-negative reception of The Village, Lady in the Water, The Happening, The Last Airbender, and After Earth, culminating in what was almost a full decade of M. Night Shyamalan gradually transforming into one of the most widely mocked filmmakers in Hollywood.
No matter what M. Night did, the connection he fawned about in the Newsweek interview waned with each passing film, sometimes resorting to mockery of his most maligned efforts. The unusual premise and execution of his environmental thriller, The Happening, has continued to live on in infamy through countless numbers of YouTube reviews and retrospectives highlighting the notoriously awkward story.
The mere utterance of What? Nooo in your most Mark Wahlberg voice has been afforded a much better fate than the two films before that, The Village and Lady in the Water, which have largely faded into obscurity, twist endings aside. The tainted reputation of The Last Airbender speaks for itself in terms of peoples thoughts on his re-imagining of the beloved show and the father-son duo of Will and Jaden Smith could not deter fans from being turned off by a new sci-fi world that failed to captivate with its post-apocalyptic setting.
No longer was M. Night Shyamalan the celebrated storyteller who took giant risks with unique setups and clever payoffs. The stories with unconventional concepts became boiled down to their concepts, seemingly leaving the stories and characters behind in the dust as a result. His director trademarks, most famously his use of an ending twist, became memes and fodder for other creators to use for their own content.
Despite all of this, Shyamalan is a filmmaker who has never failed to enter the film conversation, for better and for worse. It is likely to hear his name in discussions on the best AND worst filmmakers working today, depending on which era you would prefer to focus on.
From supernatural thrillers to action blockbusters, M. Night is the type of filmmaker who applies to the auteur theory with absolute ease. No matter his waning reputation at the time, Nights desire for audience connection remained strong with each film, even if the results were not favorable to the Oscar-nominated director. It is the type of filmography that is versatile in style and execution, but similar in trademarks (thrillers with subversive twists) that establish an identity to each film from him.
Aside from The Last Airbender, Shyamalan carved out his niche as an original director over his decades in filmmaking, blinded by the memes that some of his works have turned into now. I personally cant hear the phrase what a twist without thinking of the Robot Chicken episode that poked fun at Nights penchant for twists in his movies, yet its hard to deny the effectiveness of The Sixth Senses ending.
Praise aside, Shyamalans transition from the most sought-after filmmaker into one of the early internets most prominent punching bags is a staggering transformation that would be almost inescapable for any filmmaker. Its one thing to have some projects receive mixed reactions, but a near-decade long streak for somebody that was once called the next Spielberg is downright jarring.
But whats most interesting about Shyamalans career is the 2020s perspective. M. Night Shyamalan has made 5 movies, 2 of them to be released, since the release of After Earth and though not all of them have received the same level of acclaim as The Sixth Sense or Unbreakable, they have done well enough to earn back a level of respect from the hard-to-please film community, beginning with The Visit and continuing with the Unbreakable sequels, Split and Glass.
A decade of mockery had already done a number on Shyamalans reputation, but the mid-to-late 2010s was a time that could be best characterized as a subtle renaissance for the director. The Visit, released in 2015 and focused on two siblings documenting the strange events occurring during a visit to their grandparents house, grossed close to $100 million on a budget of $5 million and effectively gave Shyamalan his first critical success (a soft one, but a success nonetheless) since Signs.
Released through Blumhouse, Shyamalan was finally in the news for positive reactions to his film instead of the inverse. The Visit was no critical darling, but the level of distaste that had once permeated from every corner of the internet for some of his past efforts was comparatively muted. For every joke made at the films and Shyamalans expense, there were hundreds more that seemed to distance themselves from treading this path again.
The same can be applied to his next film, Split, the story of a serial killer with Dissociative Identity Disorder kidnapping three teenagers for a grim plan and the most successful film of Shyamalans post-After Earth career. A man going through several different personalities, one of them being a 9-year-old boy with a lisp, looked as though it was being set up as another meme-heavy Shyamalan production, only for it to top The Visits success at $278 million with a budget of $9 million.
The combination of James McAvoys widely acclaimed performance, the genuine mystery of the narrative, and its connection to Unbreakable catapulted the films success into pre-Signs Shyamalan, despite the man himself still being something of a stigma to audience members who remember the days of The Happening and The Last Airbender.
Shyamalans name still provokes mixed reactions from skeptical audience members or people who simply still enjoy mocking the director for their own respective reasons. Speaking from my own experience, I can still remember the chuckles and sounds of noticeable irritation when Shyamalans name popped up in the trailers for his next film and conclusion to the Unbreakable trilogy, Glass. Splits success helped rejuvenate Shyamalans career, but it has not completely wiped away the baggage that the internet saddled him with after his decade-long losing streak.
But even Glasss so-so reviews and audience reaction could not compare to the vitriol and barrage of memes that once defined an M. Night release. Released once again by Blumhouse, Glasss place in the Shyamalaniverse has been elevated purely through the unique nature of its concept and its connection to two of his most acclaimed works. Middling reviews and baggage did little to stomp out the idea that M. Night Shyamalan was lost to the film world, if his previous two films hadnt already accomplished that.
But was Shyamalan ever gone to begin with?
The idea of the infamous director reemerging as a quality filmmaker is something that is personally lost on me and heading into the 2020s, Im positive to not be the only one. There is no doubting that Shyamalan has been relatively spared the seething jokes and memes compared to other films as of late. But if we just boil down this development to the conclusion that hes just making good movies again, we ignore the fascinating trajectory of a director once slotted to become the next blockbuster master of cinema.
This was the expectation saddled onto Shyamalan early on in his career when the success of The Sixth Sense catapulted him into the mainstream. Having three critical and/or financial hits in a row naturally excited audiences to the point of painting him as one of the new standards of mainstream cinema. As is expected, when this standard is not met by the one who unwittingly set it for himself, the reaction itself is heightened as a result.
Making a well-received film is no easy task even with the right crew on hand and for all of the popular and critically adored films we see and hear about, there is a sea of poorly made projects drifting in film limbo. Seeing the early hot streak of Shyamalan seemingly wiped away the doubt of the man ever being capable of making something that couldnt instantly connect with its audience, which itself is something to tread lightly on.
Shyamalan faced a phenomenon not unlike those of movie stars; give audiences what they expect of you and you will be rewarded in return. But what exactly did audiences want from Shyamalan? Of course, wed all like movies that we enjoy and can connect with, but was that enough? When a filmmaker is dubbed the next Spielberg, how beneficial are those expectations when he ventures into unexpected territory? Why is M. Night Shyamalan back if he technically never left the scene?
Above all else, Shyamalan is a director known for the passion poured into his filmmaking. Whether his efforts are applauded or mocked, he is not especially known for half-assed directing jobs. But the power of heightened expectations can cloud even the best filmmakers mindsets on what they can or cannot make for audiences. The next Spielberg has a lot to live up to and for a director hellbent on giving mainstream audiences some semblance of originality in his films to chew on, those expectations can be more narrowing than we realize.
In an interview with Adam Sternbergh of Vulture in anticipation of Glass, Shyamalan reflects on the initial honeymoon period and how he perceived the changing aura of his later films. He uses an analogy, asking to imagine that you write a song, and suddenly everyone loves you! It seems like you have control over the fact that everyone loves you. But you dont. A simple, but telling analogy.
As his films grew bigger and expectations gradually became gargantuan compared to The Sixth Sense, Shyamalans own connection to the audience seemed to fade, even when he made something out of genuine passion. The connection that 2002 Shyamalan raved about in the Newsweek interview was lost according to 2019 Shyamalan. He further stated that he started to make movies that could be made instead of projects he truthfully wanted to make.
I think a large part of why we think of Shyamalan returning to form with The Visit has to do less with him making thriller and horror movies again (I mean, that didnt stop us from shitting on The Happening and Lady in the Water, right?) and more with him reevaluating our own perception of what to expect from an M. Night Shyamalan film. He has talked at length about essentially accepting the idea of making genre movies again after his blockbuster experiments, but I believe there to be more elements at play.
The expectations of an M. Night feature have shifted wildly over the course of his career, from high hopes to presuming the absolute worst thing imaginable. But we appear to now be at a place where we can add nuance to a career that is far more complicated than we could ever predict. The power of reflection can do so much to break the illusion of our perceived memories and with Shyamalan, it allows us to see the trailer for an upcoming Shyamalan feature and base our opinions on our own personal history with his filmography.
Night has always been considered something of a pop filmmaker, creating stories meant for mass appeal, but he has usually done so on his own terms. Shyamalans little quirks that snuck by in his films have endeared more than irritated and when expectations grew, the quirks stayed out of some conclusion that we were going to accept them no matter what kind of movie he made. Shyamalans own expectations thrown to us got the better of him for a long time. A double-edged sword.
Its as the man says; its hard to control peoples perception of you even when youre on top of the world. He spent a better part of the late 2000s trying to control the narrative that we helped jumpstart by our idea of what a Shyamalan film should provide for us and The Visit is anything but that. Hell, everything afterwards has subverted the idea of what to expect from his stories. In a way, this is potentially the best path moving forward.
It may feel backhanded to suggest that lowering our expectations have helped us accept M. Night Shyamalan again, but that isnt even whats happening here. Instead, we are in a position where we can expect just about anything from him and for a filmmaker who has long stuck with crafting original stories, it has come with unforeseen benefits.
No longer is the conversation surrounding a new M. Night feature dominated by extreme expectations on either side. When the trailer for Old released during the Super Bowl, social media reactions ranged from positive curiosity to complete disregard and everything between. But the film itself is looking to bea film from M. Night Shyamalan. He is satisfying our needs for a new horror-thriller, but he looks to be doing it on his own terms again and as a result, the auteur truly has returned to form.
I am aware of the risk of writing this piece mere months before Old releases, but whether the film succeeds or bombs is not especially relevant here. M. Night has returned with an energy that hasnt been seen in over a decade and expectations have shifted far from the types that hindered him early on.
It is a whole process of both parties gradually coming to terms with what to expect from each other. We should not be able to latch unreasonably high expectations on an unsuspecting filmmaker, just like how filmmakers shouldnt expect audiences to eat up everything they offer without a second thought.
Shyamalans rebirth in the previous decade came up from both him and us accepting the fact that not only is he not the next Spielberg, its good that hes not the next Spielberg. For all of the memes that that now-notorious magazine cover has birthed, it is ultimately an example of a narrative that should never have been started in the first place. Perhaps if that comparison was never made, his late 2000s films may have been received differently.
I dont think thats the case, but regardless of the what-ifs, Shyamalans career now fully exists in its own unique framing, for better and for worse. Its why this period of his career is being considered a renaissance even when there are still large and vocal sections of detractors. Shyamalan employs the power of connection through his vision and if the rest of his films moving forward receive negative backlash, itll be through his terms and not through those of an ill-fated magazine cover.
- Five Horror Films to Stream Now - The New York Times - October 20th, 2021
- 15 best horror movies to watch on Netflix, Amazon, HBO, and Hulu - Polygon - October 20th, 2021
- Review: Scandinavian horror movie has tremendous banalities - Ithaca College The Ithacan - October 20th, 2021
- 21 Films That Fans Chose As The Most Perfect Horror Movies To Ever Exist In Cinematic History - BuzzFeed - October 20th, 2021
- The Original Halloween Will Never Be Matched - The Atlantic - October 20th, 2021
- This twisted psychological horror movie is #1 on Netflix today - BGR - October 20th, 2021
- Horror Icon Jason Blum Reveals The Scariest Movies Hes Seen - CinemaBlend - October 20th, 2021
- 13 Scariest Horror Movie Monsters Of The 2010s, Ranked - GameSpot - October 20th, 2021
- Indie Film: The history of these Maine locales are fit for horror films - Press Herald - October 20th, 2021
- Insidious Cast: What The Stars Of The James Wan Horror Movie Are Up To Now - Cinema Blend - October 20th, 2021
- Death is Good: The Horror Films of Val Lewton | Features - Roger Ebert - October 20th, 2021
- These 7 Horror Movies Are So Outstanding, They Should Have Received Oscars - Showbiz Cheat Sheet - October 20th, 2021
- The greatest '80s horror movie of all time was shot in the Bay Area - SFGate - October 20th, 2021
- Tell Us About The Most Beautifully Breathtaking Shot You've Ever Seen In A Horror Movie - BuzzFeed - October 20th, 2021
- This nerve-shredding Netflix horror movie is finding new life ahead of Halloween - BGR - October 20th, 2021
- Lamb, Reviewed: A Horror Film Where Cleverness Is the Problem - The New Yorker - October 9th, 2021
- This is the Best Horror Movie Set in Wyoming and Here's Why - Kgab - October 9th, 2021
- Watch the First Horror Movie Written Exclusively by Bots - Nerdist - October 9th, 2021
- 'Titane' is automotive body horror and the most shockingly wholesome movie of the year - USA TODAY - October 9th, 2021
- The '70s Horror Movie That Is So Confusing It Needs A Second Watch - Looper - October 9th, 2021
- Ted Lasso is reimagined as a horror movie in creepy spoof trailer - Gamesradar - October 9th, 2021
- 15 Scary Woodland Horror Movies Set To Terrify You This Halloween - GameSpot - October 9th, 2021
- An Old Horror Film Is Dominating Streaming Today - We Got This Covered - October 9th, 2021
- The Relentless, Transgressive Horror of Titane - The Atlantic - October 9th, 2021
- Ted Lasso fan edit turns the show into a horror movie - CNET - October 9th, 2021
- 18 New Horror Movies and Shows Releasing This Week, Including 'V/H/S/94'! - Bloody Disgusting - October 9th, 2021
- This Horror Movie "Needs More Love" According To The Internet - We Got This Covered - October 9th, 2021
- This 70s Horror Film Doesn't Get Enough Love According To The Internet - We Got This Covered - October 9th, 2021
- The 15 Best '70s Horror Movies Ranked - /Film - October 9th, 2021
- 10 Horror Movies That Unbelievably Cut What We Wanted To See - WhatCulture - October 9th, 2021
- Give Female Directors Some Love! Here Are the Best Horror Movies Directed by Women - Distractify - October 9th, 2021
- The Batman Test Audience Reactions: "A Horror Movie," "Very Scary" - The Mary Sue - September 5th, 2021
- 5 horror movies have topped the box office this year and it shows why the genre is well-suited for the current market - Yahoo News - September 5th, 2021
- 20 Best Horror Movies on HBO Max for Halloween 2021 - Scary Movies to Stream on HBO Max - TownandCountrymag.com - August 24th, 2021
- The Horror Film That Was Made in Union County, KY - wbkr.com - August 24th, 2021
- 'The Last Matinee,' 'Censor,' and the power of retro horror done right - SYFY WIRE - August 24th, 2021
- [Fantasia Review] 'The Sadness' Goes for the Jugular With Transgressive, Extreme Horror - Bloody Disgusting - August 24th, 2021
- Rebecca Hall on The Night House, the Most Expertly Made Horror Movie of the Year - Vogue - August 24th, 2021
- 'District 9' Director Neill Blomkamp on His Chilling Foray into VR Horror and America-Inspired 'District 10' - The Daily Beast - August 24th, 2021
- Halloween: Every Movie In The Horror Series, Ranked - CinemaBlend - August 24th, 2021
- 14 Best Horror Movies to Stream on Amazon Prime - Your Money Geek - August 24th, 2021
- The Singing Ringing Tree Is Right Out of a Horror Movie - Nerdist - August 24th, 2021
- The Night House review: A haunted-house horror with cosmic secrets - Polygon - August 24th, 2021
- 10 Horror Movie Endings That Get Worse The More You Think About It - WhatCulture - August 24th, 2021
- Boomika movie review: Aishwarya Rajeshs film is a visually pleasing thriller with convoluted messaging - Hindustan Times - August 24th, 2021
- Whats on TV This Week: Lorde on Late Night and American Horror Story - The New York Times - August 24th, 2021
- You Might've Missed This Iconic Horror Reference In Blood Red Sky - Looper - August 24th, 2021
- The Untold Truth Of Candyman - Looper - August 24th, 2021
- Stay Home, Watch Horror: 5 Superhero Horror Movies to Stream This Week - Bloody Disgusting - August 10th, 2021
- Best horror movies on Netflix: These titles will scare you half to death - BGR - August 10th, 2021
- Aishwarya Rajeshs Boomika promises to be a gripping horror movie - The Indian Express - August 10th, 2021
- CANDYMAN and 10 Other Horror Trailers That Give Us Nightmares - Yahoo Lifestyle - August 10th, 2021
- Teddy review wince-inducing French werewolf horror - The Guardian - August 10th, 2021
- The 10 Best Horror Movies Of The 80s - We Got This Covered - August 10th, 2021
- Bleed With Me review threes a crowd in taut bloodsucking horror - The Guardian - August 10th, 2021
- The Best German Movies to Stream on Netflix Now - TownandCountrymag.com - August 10th, 2021
- How to Watch a Horror Movie: 13 Steps (with Pictures ... - July 26th, 2021
- Five Horror Movies to Stream Now - The New York Times - July 26th, 2021
- Box Office: Old Proves That M. Night Shyamalan Remains A Bankable Horror Director - Forbes - July 26th, 2021
- Netflixs new nerve-shredding horror movie has viewers jumping out of their seats - BGR - July 26th, 2021
- Netflix's New Horror Movie Has Users On The Edge Of Their Seats - We Got This Covered - July 26th, 2021
- The Action Horror Movie That Has Netflix Subscribers Gripping Their Seats - Looper - July 26th, 2021
- 40 Best Horror Movies On Hulu [July 2021] - Looper - July 26th, 2021
- Hybrid horror-LGBTQ film shot in Danbury accepted to 20 festivals - Danbury News Times - July 26th, 2021
- 13 Psychological Horror Movies That Will Destroy Your Brain For All The Wrong Reasons - GameSpot - July 26th, 2021
- 'Director's Cut' Ends the Season with Horror Film 'The Field' July 23 - PBS Wisconsin - July 26th, 2021
- How the horror genre is dying in India sans innovation and imagination - The Indian Express - July 26th, 2021
- 1960s to today: Popular movies filmed in the Las Cruces area - Las Cruces Sun-News - July 26th, 2021
- Streaming Horror Movies About the Elderly /Film - /FILM - /FILM - July 26th, 2021
- 5 Thai Horror Films on Netflix That Will Absolutely Terrify You - Tatler Singapore - July 11th, 2021
- The Vigil movie review: Amazon scores one of the most underrated horror films in years, sleepless nights await - Hindustan Times - July 11th, 2021
- The Schlock-Horror Drive-In That Rose From the Grave - The New York Times - July 11th, 2021
- Son review creepy slice of southern gothic that is the mother of all horror movies - The Guardian - July 11th, 2021
- Film 'The Medium' director says film is 'new type of horror' - The Korea Herald - July 11th, 2021
- Michelle Williams to Play King Henry VIIIs Last Wife in Horror Film Firebrand - Hollywood Reporter - July 11th, 2021
- 'The Swarm' Trailer: It's Invasion of the Killer Locusts in Netflix's New Horror Movie - /FILM - July 11th, 2021
- The Haunted House Restaurant nears opening sneak peek (photos) - cleveland.com - July 11th, 2021
- Animated Horror Movie 'The Witcher: Nightmare of the Wolf' Coming to Netflix in August [Trailer] - Bloody Disgusting - July 11th, 2021
- 10 Horror Movie Twists That Changed EVERYTHING - WhatCulture - July 11th, 2021
- The Best Horror Movies of 2021 So Far, According to Critics - Best Life - June 14th, 2021
Reviewed and Recommended by Erik Baquero