What happens now? 8-year-old Philip Levin wonders after Charles Lindbergh wins the 1940 presidential election in the HBO mini-series The Plot Against America. Later on, as the shadow of government-sanctioned anti-Semitism falls over his family and their Newark neighborhood, hell ask, What does it mean?
Philip whose name, in the 2005 book by Philip Roth, was Philip Roth is a sensitive, curious child, perhaps a novelist in the making, and more the observer of the story than its protagonist. His questions have a double significance: They cross the mind of anyone watching a narrative unfold on television, and also anyone who feels caught up in the plot of history, especially at a moment of crisis.
Like, say, now. From the perspective of the locked-down present, the road ahead looks even more forked than usual. Not only is the course of the coronavirus pandemic uncertain, but its possible social, political and economic consequences seem to point in wildly divergent directions: toward greater solidarity or intensified conflict; away from entrenched inequalities or deeper into authoritarianism; back to normal or through the looking glass.
Eventually, well know how it all turned out. But even then we might still be we might already be haunted by the sense that things could have gone differently, for good or ill. The real question Roth was asking in The Plot Against America is What if? At a time of great uncertainty, that can be an oddly reassuring question as well as a scary one, if only because it can help to be reminded that uncertainty is nothing new.
Philip Levins early-1940s world, to those of us peering into it from our early-2020s vantage, looks both familiar and outlandish. The clothes and the cars, the cigarettes and the household arrangements evoke a period encrusted with mostly benign nostalgia, a hinge moment between one era and another, when Americans listened to Franklin D. Roosevelt on the radio and Pearl Harbor was just around the corner.
The ingenuity of Roths novel and the mostly faithful television adaptation created by David Simon and Ed Burns lies in the way this easy familiarity is twisted into terror. The series is at times almost unbearably suspenseful because most stories set in the years just before World War II are the opposite. History is by definition spoiler-free. (Unlike this article, which will divulge information about The Plot Against America and several other movies and television series.) We never stop arguing about what it means, but we pretty much agree on what happened next.
But The Plot Against America isnt history. Its characters, an extended, fractious family of lower-middle-class Jews, are trapped in an alternative timeline in which the unthinkable has become commonplace. A bigoted celebrity with no political experience, running on an America First platform (and possibly in the employ of an undemocratic foreign power) spoils the hopes of the Democratic Party for a third consecutive term in the White House. An admirer of Hitler (as the historical Lindbergh notoriously was), the new president initiates policies that undermine the standing and the confidence of Americas Jewish citizens, who are exposed to open prejudice, stigmatization and, ultimately, violence. Somebody name-checks Sinclair Lewiss cautionary 1935 best seller, It Cant Happen Here. Roth, Simon and Burns reply: But suppose that it did.
Counterfactualism of this kind has never found much favor in the historical profession. And it isnt always welcome in popular culture, either. Earlier this year, HBO canceled Confederate, a proposed series from the creators of Game of Thrones about what America might have looked like if the North hadnt won the Civil War. But there is a lot of what-if in the air these days, as the notion of multiple timelines migrates from science fiction into more conventionally realistic narratives.
Before Roths Plot, the most significant work of American prose fiction to grapple with an opposite past was probably Philip K. Dicks The Man in the High Castle, which also imagined that fascism, rather than being defeated in the 1940s, had triumphed. The television adaptation, running for four seasons on Amazon Prime, was an early example of the current vogue for alternative history in film and television.
Quentin Tarantino got there first. With Inglorious Basterds (2009), Django Unchained (2012) and last years Once Upon a Time in Hollywood, Tarantino, in spite of his taste for nihilistic violence, has become a leading purveyor of happy endings and lucky breaks, a master of upbeat what-iffery. What if Hitler and the Nazi elite had been knocked off in June 1944, done in by two scrappy overlapping conspiracies rather than millions of American, British and Soviet soldiers? What if the enslaved people of the antebellum South had collected their payback directly from their oppressors, rather than waiting for the Civil War? And what if, Charles Mansons followers had never made it to Sharon Tates house on Cielo Drive in August 1969?
What happens is that the audience is treated to a consoling fantasy, a momentary release from the fatalism that weighs down real historical knowledge. The hedonism of succumbing to this kind of dream is linked to the masochistic pleasures of dystopian nightmare-mongering. The alternative past and the dystopian future are explicitly connected in Watchmen, which ran on HBO last fall and which wove history both real (the 1921 Tulsa Race Massacre) and fanciful (the presidency of Robert Redford) into a wildly inventive, thrillingly revisionist critique of the superhero genre.
Its a commonplace that chronicles of the grim future of ecological catastrophe, technological domination, totalitarian politics project the anxieties of the present. The Handmaids Tale, in both its print and television forms (two novels by Margaret Atwood; three seasons on Hulu created by Bruce Miller), can stand in for the many stories that combine allegory and warning. This is what life might look like if we arent careful, and also what it already is like if we look carefully.
The theocratic, authoritarian Republic of Gilead in Handmaid isnt meant to be another world, but an at least arguably plausible extrapolation of the one we already inhabit. Misogyny, religious extremism and environmental harm are already threads in the tapestry of reality. They were present when Atwood wrote the first novel in the early 1980s, and also when Miller brought them into brighter, bolder relief at the end of the 2010s.
It isnt hard to imagine a path from here to there from America to Gilead and part of the nerve-racking, scary-movie pleasure of The Handmaids Tale is what it suggests about how we, the citizens of a democracy, turned into them, the subjects and functionaries of a clerical-fascist police state. The story doesnt play out as a simple matter of good and evil, but rather as a series of political and ethical puzzles. How does the nature of state power change? Does human character change along with it?
Those are the kinds of questions that animate Years and Years, a British mini-series created by Russell T. Davies and shown on HBO last summer. It may have been just a little ahead of its time. Catching up with its 10 episodes last month, I found the story almost unbearably relevant, which may or may not be a recommendation.
The approach is more linear than the embedded flashbacks and digressions of the later seasons of The Handmaids Tale. A recognizable now Brexit, climate change, President Trump, Sino-American tensions mutates by sometimes almost imperceptible increments into an ever more alarming then. A populist demagogue (played by Emma Thompson) starts out as the semi-comical figurehead of a vague protest movement until shockingly, inevitably, she is elected prime minister. Anti-immigrant politics and the specter of Russian meddling in a Western election flicker across the screen. The economy collapses. When the global pandemic arrives, its almost an afterthought.
All of these events as well as developments in digital technology that hardly seem science-fictional at all are refracted through the experiences of the Lyons family, a multigenerational, multiracial clan living mainly in Manchester. The Lyons are sometimes hit hard by global conflicts and catastrophes, but they also go through the usual domestic throes of marriage, adultery and divorce, childbirth and adolescence, sibling rivalry and in-law issues.
Like the Levins in Newark, they dont all respond consistently or in the same way, and arent easily sorted into heroes and villain. Each member of the family represents a slightly different blend or sequence of compromise and resistance, wishful thinking and panic, cowardice and grit. Most of them believe that things will be all right in the end.
Which turns out big spoiler here to be true. Optimism is vindicated in a climax that I found both thrilling and frustrating. Thrilling because of the way some characters find the pluck and ingenuity to score a big victory against the forces of repression and xenophobia, and frustrating because their triumph seemed much less realistic than anything in the previous episodes. When videos of flagrant injustice go viral around the world, the world wakes from its slumber, snatching the possibility of an engaged democratic future from the jaws of tyranny and cynicism.
It would be nice to believe that, but history often speaks in the voice of Marlo Stanfield in The Wire: You want it to be one way, but its the other way. That is the unnerving message of Watchmen and The Plot Against America. We think of superhero stories the genetic material of Watchmen one way: as tales of righteous, disguised vigilantes fighting crime outside the boundaries of the law. Watchmen suggests another way, drawing out a subtext of racism and ideological bad blood that had been there all along.
Modern superheroism in this telling originates in the Tulsa Race Massacre, a real-world act of terror that took scores of lives and laid waste to a prosperous African-American neighborhood, only to be euphemized (as a riot) and treated, at best, as an unfortunate sidebar in the textbooks. Placing it at the center of the story scrambles both the familiar comic-book landscape and the culture-war folklore that underlies it. Law and order, rebellion and obedience, liberal and conservative, black and white none of these words mean quite what we thought they did.
That dislocation is both exhilarating and terrifying, a description that fits The Plot Against America as well, though the scrupulous naturalism of its methods is a world away from the phantasmagoria of Watchmen. Roth took exquisite care to replace just one thread in the American tapestry, and to confine the Lindbergh presidency to a single episode. Like Years and Years, his book ends with a return to normalcy, a reversion to the familiar timeline signaled by references to later events Roosevelts death in office; Robert F. Kennedys assassination that will happen they way we always thought they would. Halfway into his term, as the country convulses in its own version of Kristallnacht, Lindbergh takes off, paving the way for a special election that will return Roosevelt to power.
The nightmare was over, young Philip Roth says. Its effect on him is registered with chilling matter-of-factness: Never again would I be able to revive that unfazed sense of security first fostered in a little child by a big, protective republic and his ferociously responsible parents. In other words, the Philip Roth we know, who turned that youthful security into a confident assertion of Jewish-American identity and made those parents into comical but nonetheless heroic embodiments of American-Jewish normalcy would have written his books some other way.
This is unsettling, but Simon and Burnss version goes further, turning Roths subtly furious mock memoir into a seething, ambiguous allegory. In the wrenching final episode, were looking not at an imagined past but at an alternative present and a possible future. The series ends with a cliffhanger, a lady-or-the-tiger moment of nonresolution that transforms Roths speculative history into a political challenge. Maybe things will be all right, and maybe they wont. History is a nightmare from which none of us can wake. Imagining it otherwise isnt so much a challenge to the truth as it is a protest against necessity. It didnt have to be that way. It doesnt have to be this way.
View post:
Once Upon a Timeline in America - The New York Times
- Nicolas Cage is set to take on another horror movie, this time about Jesus? - Gamesradar - May 9th, 2024
- Horror Tips from Director Jeff Wadlow and the Set of 'Imaginary' - No Film School - May 9th, 2024
- Upcoming horror movie amps up its marketing by having crazed killers pop up all over the nation - Gamesradar - May 9th, 2024
- This Upcoming Horror Movie Is The Best Chance Of 2024 Beating Five Night's At Freddy's Box Office - Screen Rant - May 9th, 2024
- Abigail Lands on Digital Platforms 2 Weeks After Theater Release: How to Stream the Horror Movie Online - Billboard - May 9th, 2024
- Stephen King Praises 'Scary' and 'Gross' Horror Movie With Near-Perfect Reviews - CBR - May 9th, 2024
- 'Mind Body Spirit' Review: A Horror Movie That Puts a Yoga Twist on 'Hereditary' - Collider - May 9th, 2024
- Nicolas Cage Is Taking on a New Horror Movie of Biblical Proportions - Collider - May 9th, 2024
- Daylight horror: 12 movies that are still scary with the lights on - The A.V. Club - May 9th, 2024
- How To Watch Tarot: Is the Horror Movie Streaming or in Theaters? - TheWrap - May 9th, 2024
- Mind Body Spirit Review: A Found Footage Horror Film With Something To Say About The Influencer Age - Screen Rant - May 9th, 2024
- This Unexpectedly Great Horror Movie Reboot With 80% On Rotten Tomatoes Is Now Streaming & I Wish I Saw It In ... - Screen Rant - May 9th, 2024
- The horror movie so realistic its director was arrested for murder - JOE.ie - May 9th, 2024
- 'Tarot' Scares Up a Bleak Weekend at the Global Box Office - Collider - May 9th, 2024
- Insane 2024 horror movie with a twist hits 95% on Rotten Tomatoes - Dexerto - May 9th, 2024
- 10 of the Most Disturbing 2024 Horror Movies You (Probably) Haven't Heard Of - Dread Central - May 9th, 2024
- EXPOSURE: This Short Film Will Make You Want To Throw Your Security Cameras In A Dumpster - FANGORIA - May 9th, 2024
- 5 New Horror Movies Releasing This Week Including 'Abigail' at Home - Bloody Disgusting - May 9th, 2024
- The Best Horror Movies Streaming This Month Will Make Your Skin Crawl (May 2024) - SlashFilm - May 9th, 2024
- This Surreal Horror Movie on Max Is One of the Most Influential Films Ever - Collider - May 9th, 2024
- The 30 best classic horror movies of all time - Entertainment Weekly News - March 16th, 2024
- The 23rd Spring, Is Jeepers Creepers Coming Back To Michigan? - 102.5/104.9 The Block - March 16th, 2024
- Winnie The Pooh Horror Movie Dominates The Razzie Awards - 106.3 The Groove - March 16th, 2024
- This Underrated Blumhouse Horror Movie Is Unlike Any Other Creature Feature - Collider - March 16th, 2024
- 13 Horror Movies Where Everyone Dies by the End - MovieWeb - March 8th, 2024
- Willy Wonka Experience Villain The Unknown Gets Its Own Horror Movie - TMZ - March 8th, 2024
- The 13 Scariest Horror Movies Streaming on Peacock: Alien, Leprechaun, The Exorcist: Believer and More - Syfy - March 8th, 2024
- Every Horror Movie Releasing in March 2024 - MovieWeb - March 8th, 2024
- 10 Scariest Movies That Have Won Oscars - Collider - March 8th, 2024
- The 10 Best New Horror Movies To Watch in March 2024 - Collider - March 8th, 2024
- Horror Movie Based on Viral Willy Wonka Experience Coming Soon - Bloody Disgusting - March 8th, 2024
- Where To Watch Imaginary: Showtimes & Streaming Status - Screen Rant - March 8th, 2024
- Immaculate: Eveything You Need to Know About Sydney Sweeney's Upcoming Horror Movie That Will Give You ... - FandomWire - March 8th, 2024
- The 20 best horror movies on Peacock - Entertainment Weekly News - March 8th, 2024
- Horror Movie Based on the Willy Wonka Experience Villain, The Unknown, Now in the Works - MovieWeb - March 8th, 2024
- Melissa Barrera's Scream 7 Replacement Actually Sounds Better Than Fighting Ghostface Again - Screen Rant - March 8th, 2024
- 'Shaitaan' Movie 2024 Filming Locations: Shooting Spots Of The Horror Flick - TRAVEL + LEISURE INDIA - March 8th, 2024
- The Horror Movie Franchise With the Most Sequels Ever Is One You've Never Heard of - Collider - March 8th, 2024
- Jimmy Fallon asked people to ruin a horror movie by adding a single word to its title - Upworthy - March 8th, 2024
- The Absolute Best Horror Movies on Hulu - CNET - March 8th, 2024
- Willy Wonka Experience creepy character 'The Unknown' handed role in new horror movie - The Mirror - March 8th, 2024
- The Best Sea Monster Movies, Ranked - Screen Rant - February 28th, 2024
- The Borderlands Movie's Scary Behind The Scenes Drama That Has Us Worried - Screen Rant - February 28th, 2024
- Netflix Just Quietly Added the Best Holiday Thriller of the Decade - Inverse - February 28th, 2024
- The 20 best scary movies streaming right now - Entertainment Weekly News - February 19th, 2024
- Best Horror Movies of 2024 Ranked - New Scary Movies to Watch - Rotten Tomatoes - February 19th, 2024
- 'Only Murders in the Building' Adds Molly Shannon to Season 4 Cast - Yahoo Eurosport UK - February 19th, 2024
- Why Lindsay Lohan Refused to Kiss Charlie Sheen in "Scary Movie 5" - Best Life - February 19th, 2024
- 15 Best Scary Movies To Stream - Screen Rant - February 11th, 2024
- Eight Skin-Crawling Scary Films That Don't Have Any Jump Scares In Them - Digg - February 11th, 2024
- David Cronenberg names some of the scariest movies ever - Far Out Magazine - February 11th, 2024
- 12 Horror Movies That Will Give You the Biggest Jump Scares - Collider - February 3rd, 2024
- TAROT's Trailer Brings the Iconic Cards to Life and Things Get Weird - Nerdist - February 3rd, 2024
- Review: Baghead - Is the Movie as Scary as it Looks? - Blazing Minds - February 3rd, 2024
- Natasha Lyonne Says James Woods Hit On Her As A Teenager While Filming Scary Movie 2 - 106.3 The Groove - February 3rd, 2024
- The Witcher's Freya Allan explains the challenges of filming her first horror movie Baghead: "You have to surrender ... - Gamesradar - January 26th, 2024
- The 5 Best Uses of Popcorn in Scary Movies - Dread Central - January 26th, 2024
- 5 Horror Films That Transformed The Genre - Study Finds - January 26th, 2024
- Kristen Stewart Wants to Star in Another Horror Movie in the Future - ComingSoon.net - January 26th, 2024
- Best Home Invasion Movies of All Time, Ranked - MovieWeb - January 26th, 2024
- Presence Review: Steven Soderbergh Tells a Ghost Story from the Ghosts POV. It Is Scary? Not Quite. But the Family Demons Lure You In - Variety - January 26th, 2024
- 55 best horror movies that are actually good and terrifying - Digital Spy - January 18th, 2024
- She is a Real Housewife, was in a scary movie franchise, is pals with Bethenny Frankel, has a Hilton connectio - Daily Mail - January 18th, 2024
- The Scream cast talk about the legacy of Scary Movie - Popverse - January 9th, 2024
- The 20 Best Horror Movies on Netflix: January 2024 - Vulture - January 9th, 2024
- Scream cast reveals their favorite scary movies - Popverse - January 9th, 2024
- Horror fanatics are 'desperate' to watch the first scary movie of the year Night Swim after trailer leaves the - Daily Mail - January 9th, 2024
- 20 Scariest Horror Movies That Are Too Disturbing to Re-Watch - Collider - January 1st, 2024
- Raging Grace review politicised critique of imperialism in horror movie form - The Guardian - January 1st, 2024
- 15 Scariest Horror Movies of All Time, According to Rotten Tomatoes - MovieWeb - January 1st, 2024
- The 19 Best Horror Films of 2023 Best Life - Best Life - January 1st, 2024
- The Best Horror Movies of 2021, Ranked by Tomatometer - Rotten Tomatoes - December 23rd, 2023
- This Is What Takes 'The Descent' From Scary to Terrifying - Collider - December 23rd, 2023
- 15 Best Horror Movies Of 2023 - Screen Rant - December 23rd, 2023
- 25 Best Horror Movies Created in the Last 5 Years - CBR - Comic Book Resources - December 12th, 2023
- 25 horror movies that were based on true stories - Yardbarker - December 12th, 2023
- The 30 best horror movies of all time - Gamesradar - December 12th, 2023
- Scary Movies In Theaters Now (2023/12/06)- Tickets to Movies in Theaters, Broadway Shows, London Theatre & More - Hollywood.com - December 12th, 2023
- What Is the Highest Grossing Horror Movie of All Time? - Collider - December 12th, 2023
- The 27 Best Horror Films of 2023 - MarieClaire.com - December 12th, 2023
Reviewed and Recommended by Erik Baquero