To pay attention to U.S. transportation politics is to adopt a warped sense of time. Words like quickly and slowly lose most common meanings, and horizons telescope outward, until the year 2027 seems to be pretty soon. At the same time, big decisions made a decade ago can continue to haunt the present, as if they are still being decided over and over again.
Such is the case with Minneapolis Nicollet streetcar project, where a plan that dates to 2007 is still causing mild havoc in Minneapolis policy circles.
Article continues after advertisement
One things for sure: Nobody wants to talk publicly about the Nicollet streetcar these days. After reaching out to multiple past and present city officials over the past few weeks, I was able to procure exactly one quote. Here it is, courtesy of the mayors office:
Equitable transit remains a top priority for Mayor Frey and he will continue prioritizing inclusive transit options for Minneapolis residents. Nicollet Avenue is an important corridor as noted in the Citys newly adopted Transportation Action Plan and the City is exploring all options, especially in light of the newly acquired K-mart site, and the opportunity to reconnect neighborhoods.
Back in 2018, Mayor Frey admitted while on stage with the Theater of Public Policy that the Nicollet streetcar was dead. When pressed to elaborate, Frey had this to say:
Im for the benefit of a streetcar, not for the transportation side but for the economic development that it could trigger along these corridors that need a little bit of a bump. Uptown is bumpin. Downtown is happenin. Northeast is rockin. Up until you get to around the plan was for it to go across the river and get to Central, and then to basically turn around. The portion of the city that could use a little bit of economic development is from the Central/Hennepin crossroad further down Central. Theres 5-6 blocks there where we could do something pretty amazing. But if the streetcar is not going that far anyway, whats the point? I think we should be investing heavily in BRT.
If you talk to people off the record, nobody likes the Nicollet streetcar proposal, at least not as its currently drafted. Everyone I spoke to wants the city to prioritize different investments, and nobody thinks that the economic future of downtown or northeast hinges on a three-mile streetcar running from Lake Street to Northeast Central Avenue.
Meanwhile, the word streetcar only appears once in the newly adopted 2020 city Transportation Action Plan, to refer to a section deleted from the previous 2011 version. An omission like that is never an accident.
Yet despite being dead, the Nicollet streetcar retains a kind of zombie status. For example, the RBC Gateway project, a 37-story building under construction at the key Hennepin and Washington corner, includes a theoretical easement for a streetcar to cut kitty-corner through its lot. And in a recent Met Council aBRT study to select the metros next bus rapid transit line (the F Line), a proposed Nicollet Avenue alignment was automatically eliminated because streetcar planning is taking place.
So why is a dead project still causing ripples in the Twin Cities transit pool? Is the Nicollet streetcar dead, or isnt it?
Article continues after advertisement
That the answer remains murky has everything to do with a special pot of money, at least $20 million dollars that has been legally set aside for the streetcar project that nobody really wants. Because the money is there, nobody is willing to officially kill the streetcar plan. And so it lives on.
The Nicollet streetcar project dates back at least to 2007, the middle of the R.T. Rybak administration, where it was the brainchild of policy director Peter Wagenius. At the time, parts of Minneapolis around the edge of downtown were not developing very quickly, and the City Council commissioned a study to examine the feasibility of a streetcar running through downtown. The resulting plan laid out lines connecting the downtown core with surrounding neighborhoods, at which point the lines were winnowed down to one that would serve as the highest priority: a connection from Lake Street up Nicollet Avenue over the river into Northeast, and stopping at Central Avenue.
City of Minneapolis
A map of the Nicollet-Central streetcar.
If ambitious streetcar plans made any real difference, U.S. cities would look very different from the way they do today. Rather, the problem with U.S. streetcars has always been money, as federal funding policies give short shrift to anything thats not a freeway or an expensive (light or heavy) rail line. And without federal money, nothing happens.
Thats why the brilliant move for Minneapolis Nicollet Avenue streetcar was the inclusion of a special value capture funding source, what my Cityscape predecessor called a pretty clever device. Thanks to a state law passed in 2012, the City of Minneapolis, only in this specific instance, has set aside tax dollars from five specific development parcels. All of that property tax revenue since then has been accumulating for the project.
Despite the lack of streetcar champions in Minneapolis City Hall, the money has been building up. It even came in handy last year when, thanks to a liberal interpretation of the streetcar legislation, Minneapolis allocated almost $10 million of the fund to pay the retailer to end its lease at the long-maligned Kmart site at Lake Street (and the spot where Nicollet should be). In 2017 it used $7 million from the fund to buy the property under the Kmart.
Article continues after advertisement
The downtown streetcar trend
Another longstanding rule of transportation wonkery is that certain types of projects become trendy, peak, and disappear. The 1970s saw the popularity of the people movers (actually built in Detroit and Seattle), while the late 2000s were the heyday of downtown streetcar loops. (The trends these days revolve around self-driving cars and the immensely impractical hyper loop.)
Blame or credit for the 21st century U.S. streetcar trend can be placed at the feet of Portland, Oregon. Its downtown Pearl District streetcar line opened in 2001 and became closely linked to the resulting wave of downtown development in a great many urban planning PowerPoint presentations. As a result, more than a dozen downtown streetcar projects have been built around the country none of which extend for more than 4 total miles. Most of them are half that distance.
MinnPost photo by Bill Lindeke
Blame or credit for the 21st century U.S. streetcar trend can be placed at the feet of Portland, Oregon.
As Frey pointed out in his 2018 interview, the winds of transit policy have begun to blow against downtown streetcars in favor of far more affordable and practical projects like the Metro Transit aBRT program.
One reason nobody at City Hall wants to officially kill the Nicollet Streetcar is that, in general, U.S. cities have more trouble funding things than they ought to. State laws have long placed strict restrictions on municipal taxes, and the big cities most flexible tax arrangement, tax-increment financing (TIF),comes with a lot of strings and restrictions about how it can be used.
Those fiscal limits are a double-edged sword, to be sure. They prevent cities from spending scarce resources on boondoggles, but at the same time, they keep cities from making good investments with their resources. All this is to say that having a pot of city-controlled money available through a value-capture district [PDF] is not necessarily a bad idea. But once a project like the Nicollet streetcar is funded, it becomes extremely hard to kill it, and Minneapolis pot of money is eventually going to have to go somewhere. At some point, Minneapolis will have to either build its dubious streetcar, which nobody quite wants to do, pull some serious legal strings to rewrite its state legislative streetcar-funding permission slip, or else be creative. A generous reading of the legislation could permit the funds to be used in ways similar to the Kmart acquisition plan, such as improving transit stations that might benefit the existing buses that already run on Nicollet every day.
But thats fine-grained hair-splitting, and cannot be done if plans for the streetcar disappear. The alternative is to simply abolish the special tax district, returning somewhere between $5 million and $10 million a year back into the citys general fund to pay for things like city services, staffing, and (the ever increasing) police budget. To do this would be to lose the flexibility and impact of the tax district, and a special pot of money that might theoretically be a boon to a creative or ambitious city politician.
Article continues after advertisement
Though nobody will actually admit it, a Nicollet Avenue streetcar is not likely to be built. Nobody in City Hall really supports it; it doesnt fit well into the Met Council regional planning; downtown and northeast economic development is hardly a priority in 2020; and the national examples of similar projects are not very impressive these days.
At least well always have that one amazing streetcar rendering, depicting a car in mixed traffic at 26th and Nicollet, with a few cars threatening to block the tracks in front of the station.
- Indias zombie home fund set to deliver thousands of apartments - The Real Deal - February 20th, 2021
- Zombie infection threat as country unlocks 50,000-year-old viruses - Yahoo News Australia - February 20th, 2021
- Stubbs the Zombie rises from his grave this March for PC via Steam - PC Invasion - February 20th, 2021
- Zombie Hit Train To Busan Is Getting A US Remake - GameSpot - February 20th, 2021
- Rob Zombie says the meat industrys future is unsustainable - NME.com - February 20th, 2021
- Stubbs The Zombie In Rebel Without A Pulse - Yahoo Entertainment - February 20th, 2021
- Batista Wanted To Play A Zombie On The Walking Dead, Rejected For Being "Too Big" - Fightful - February 20th, 2021
- Dave Bautista told he was too big to play zombie on The Walking Dead - NME - February 17th, 2021
- Dave Bautista Offered To Play A Zombie For Free On The Walking Dead - Screen Rant - February 17th, 2021
- Is plurilateralism making the WTO an institutional zombie? - East Asia Forum - February 17th, 2021
- REVIEW: Zom 100: Bucket List of the Dead, Vol. 1 is a Comedic Zombie Apocalypse - CBR - Comic Book Resources - February 17th, 2021
- Don't Eat Pete is a zombie survival game that's available now for Android in Early Access - Pocket Gamer - February 17th, 2021
- Call of Duty Warzone seems to be teasing Zombies - Gamesradar - February 17th, 2021
- James Gunn Weighs In On Whether Zombies Or Vampires Are More Dangerous - Looper - February 17th, 2021
- The Walking Dead back on the march - Stuff.co.nz - February 17th, 2021
- The Walking Dead Turned Dave Bautista Down for a Zombie Role - Superherohype.com - February 16th, 2021
- Army of the Dead Image Teases Zombie Heist Movie - /FILM - February 16th, 2021
- The Real Life Diet of Rob Zombie, Who Thinks Eating Vegan Is Metal - British GQ - February 16th, 2021
- Rob Zombie says veganism is about 'fighting the establishment' - Vegan Food and Living - February 16th, 2021
- The Next Generation of Marvel Zombies Is Already in the Marvel Universe - CBR - Comic Book Resources - February 16th, 2021
- It Looks Like Zombies Are Coming To Warzone Season 2 | TheGamer - TheGamer - February 16th, 2021
- ROB ZOMBIE Explains Why He Went Vegan "It Is Anti-Establishment" - Metal Injection - February 14th, 2021
- Zombie Baseballs and MLBs Home Run Problem - The Wall Street Journal - February 14th, 2021
- Rob Zombie Thinks Eating Vegan Is Metal - GQ - February 14th, 2021
- This is what the DoD has planned for a zombie apocalypse - We Are The Mighty - February 14th, 2021
- 3 Cookbooks and guides to teach you how to survive during the eventual zombie apocalypse - Undead Walking - February 14th, 2021
- Call Of Duty Zombies: All Zombies Crews, Ranked - TheGamer - February 14th, 2021
- Tesla : Which is the best EV to own to survive a zombie apocalypse? - marketscreener.com - February 14th, 2021
- Here's How You Can Watch Every Season Of iZombie - Looper - February 14th, 2021
- What's The 1st Thing You'd Grab If Zombies Invaded Twin Falls? - kezj.com - February 14th, 2021
- Kennedy: Banks, communities need to collaborate on zombie property upkeep - The Daily Gazette - February 10th, 2021
- Zombies Attack Bend! [With Video] - The Source Weekly - February 10th, 2021
- Ten Zombie Comedies That Won't Rot Your Braaaaaaaains - tor.com - February 10th, 2021
- These Bulletproof Vehicles Are Perfect For Surviving The Zombie Apocalypse - HotCars - February 10th, 2021
- How a Left 4 Dead Remaster Could Revive the Zombie Shooter Genre - CBR - Comic Book Resources - February 10th, 2021
- Rise of Barnegat Light's Zombie Whale; It Starts With Dead Bigfoots, the Devils - The SandPaper - February 10th, 2021
- The Senate should do everything it can to avoid a zombie impeachment trial - CNN - February 9th, 2021
- 8 Video Game Zombies That Break the Traditional Mold - Bloody Disgusting - February 9th, 2021
- Zombie Reddy Four Days Box Office Collection, Teja Sajja's Film Is Ruling The Box Office. - Sakshi Post - February 9th, 2021
- Colm O'Regan: The perfect Valentine's Day gift - a zombie plan for the one you love - Irish Examiner - February 9th, 2021
- Zombie Reddy Third Day Box Office Collection, Teja Sajja's Film Passes The Weekend On A Phenomenal Note - Sakshi Post - February 9th, 2021
- How to Play the Witch Role Mod in Among Us | Screen Rant - Screen Rant - February 9th, 2021
- Reanimation and Zombies: Discussion with author Frank Swain - WLNS - February 9th, 2021
- Stubbs the Zombie Is Returning In a Unique Re-release From Aspyr Media - Happy Gamer - February 9th, 2021
- Author discussion to explore reanimation, zombies - The Hillsdale Daily News - February 9th, 2021
- Not Ready to Die: These 5 'zombie' cars were sold alongside their replacements - Driving - February 5th, 2021
- Zombie Reddy movie review: When the zombies attack Seema - The Hindu - February 5th, 2021
- Stubbs the Zombie comes back from the dead in March, achievements revealed - TrueAchievements - February 5th, 2021
- Prasanth Varma: Zombie Reddy doesnt make a joke out of zombies - The Indian Express - February 5th, 2021
- Stubbs the Zombie Re-Release Launching in March | Game Rant - GameRant - February 5th, 2021
- Shang-Chi Finally Found the Cure for the Newest Kind of Marvel Zombie - CBR - Comic Book Resources - February 5th, 2021
- Free-Roam VR Unleashed - The Source Weekly - February 5th, 2021
- Releasing Today: Zombie Attack On Box Office.. - Greatandhra.com - February 5th, 2021
- ROB ZOMBIE's New Album Was Completed A Couple Years Ago - Metal Injection - February 5th, 2021
- Zombie nation: Third of adults walking around in concussion-like daze due to stress, lack of sleep - Study Finds - February 5th, 2021
- Stubbs the Zombie Achievements Listing Hints a Re-release in March - The Nerd Stash - February 5th, 2021
- Stubbs the Zombie in Rebel Without a Pulse Re-Release Hinted - NoobFeed - February 5th, 2021
- Splunking the Zombie Apocalypse - Security Boulevard - February 4th, 2021
- The Last of Us Meets The Division In Zombie MMO The Day Before - Screen Rant - February 4th, 2021
- Zombie-Bite Politics - The Dispatch - The Dispatch - February 4th, 2021
- World War Z & 9 More Of The Highest-Grossing Zombie Movies Of All Time - Screen Rant - February 4th, 2021
- AOC's terrifying account of the Capitol siege: 'It almost felt like a zombie movie' - CNET - February 4th, 2021
- Korean Zombie says he hit rock bottom and gained over 40 lbs after loss to Brian Ortega - Bloody Elbow - February 4th, 2021
- Varun Tej heaps praise on Teja Sajja at Zombie Reddy pre-release event - Times of India - February 4th, 2021
- Cold War Zombies: How to Upgrade The D.I.E Shockwave - Screen Rant - February 4th, 2021
- ROB ZOMBIE Releases New Single And Video 'The Eternal Struggles Of The Howling Man' | Scoop News - Scoop.co.nz - February 4th, 2021
- THE WALKING DEAD Season 10 "Ties that Bind" Trailer (2021) Zombie Horror - JoBlo.com - February 4th, 2021
- Feeding monopolies and zombies: Made in the USA: Socialism for the Rich. Capitalism for the Rest - The Times of India Blog - January 30th, 2021
- Hear Rob Zombie's Raucous New Song "The Eternal Struggles of the Howling Man" - Revolver Magazine - January 30th, 2021
- The Korean Zombie says he hit rock bottom and gained 20kgs following loss to Brian Ortega - BJPENN.COM - January 30th, 2021
- ROB ZOMBIE To Release A New Song This Friday - Metal Injection - January 30th, 2021
- The Day Before Is Basically The Division with Zombie-like Infected - Wccftech - January 30th, 2021
- USM Alumna's Novel Included on Best Fiction for Young Adults List - Southern Miss Now - January 30th, 2021
- Zombies and Neon Fury Star in Howie Lees Insane New Music Video - RADII - January 30th, 2021
- This $23 emergency radio is all you need to survive the zombie (or robot) apocalypse - CNET - January 25th, 2021
- The real zombie threat as the Arctic thaws and other climate briefs - Haaretz - January 25th, 2021
- When the zombies come, I will be ready - Rochelle News Leader - January 25th, 2021
- The information warriors fighting 'robot zombie army' of coronavirus sceptics - The Guardian - January 25th, 2021
- Tips To Survive An Infinite Number Of Rounds In Black Ops: Cold Wars Zombies Mode - TheGamer - January 25th, 2021
- Yungblud and Machine Gun Kelly tease zombie film-inspired 'Acting Like That' video - NME.com - January 25th, 2021
Reviewed and Recommended by Erik Baquero