Photo by Simon Wijers on UnSplash
Update: on December 10 the DEP responded to the LRB's November 30 letter, stating correctly that "given the clear and specific process laid out in the Regulatory Review Act, there is no legal authority for the LRB to substitute its own interpretation of the statute as a rationale for failing to perform its administrative role in the regulatory process," and that "[s]ince both the Attorney General and the General Counsel approved the CO2 Budget Trading Program final rulemaking for form and legality, your office is required to publish" the Program regulation.
In mylast blog, I discussed how Republican leaders in the Pennsylvania General Assembly were using the state Regulatory Review Act (RRA) to delay finalization of the DEPs proposed CO2 Budget Trading Program regulation, which would enable the Commonwealth to participate in the Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative (RGGI).
This blog is about the latest twist in that story: after the Wolf administration delivered the regulation to the state Legislative Reference Bureau following a form and legality review by the Attorney General, the Bureau refused to publish it in the Pennsylvania Bulletin, thereby blocking it from formally becoming law. The reason? The Bureau is misinterpreting the RRA. The result: unless the Wolf administration goes to court, Pennsylvania will have to wait for months to experience the benefits of RGGI: healthier air, lower carbon pollution, and the opportunity to invest hundreds of millions of dollars in the Commonwealths communities and workers.
Waitthe Legislative Reference what?
The main job of theLegislative Reference Bureau, or LRB, is to draft bills for legislators. Its role in Pennsylvanias regulatory rulemaking process generally goes unremarked because, as a rule, its unremarkable: at the end of the long process prescribed by the RRA, the LRB publishes regulations in the Bulletin. Thats how regulations are officially "promulgated" in Pennsylvania.
What the LRB does not do is make important legal or regulatory policy decisions - at least not until now. Things changed in late November, when, after the House failed to take timely action on a "resolution of disapproval" passed by the Senate, the DEP delivered the RGGI regulation to the LRB and got thisresponse: "our office is not authorized at this time to publish the Environmental Quality Board Final Rulemaking #7-559: C02 Budget Trading Program, submitted November 29, 2021. Currently, Senate Concurrent Regulatory Review Resolution l (S.C.R.R.R. 1) disapproving Final Rulemaking #7-559 is still pending before the House of Representatives."
For reasons explained below, this was a legally incorrect decision, and it will have consequences. If the LRB were fulfilling its lawful duty, the RGGI regulation could be published by the end of the year, and that would put Pennsylvania in position to participate in the first RGGI allowance auction of 2022, in March.
In refusing to publish the regulation, however, the LRB is choosing to embrace a dubious and self-serving interpretation of the RRA by House and Senate Republicans that would delay Pennsylvania's participation in RGGI until the second quarter of 2022 (at the earliest) and set a harmful precedent for all state agency rulemakings
How did we end up here?
Under the RRA, the legislature can kill a proposed regulation by first passing a timely resolution of disapproval and then, if the Governor vetoes the resolution, by overriding the veto with two-thirds supermajorities in both chambers. For present purposes, the key section of the law is 7(d), which says that when a resolution of disapproval has been passed (or reported") by an appropriate legislative committee, the Senate and the House of Representatives shall each have 30 calendar days or ten legislative days, whichever is longer, from the date on which the concurrent resolution has been reported, to adopt the concurrent resolution . . . If the General Assembly does not adopt the concurrent resolution or override the veto in the time prescribed in this subsection, it shall be deemed to have approved the final-form . . . regulation. [Emphasis added]
The Senate Environmental Resources and Energy Committee reported a timely resolution of disapproval on September 14, and the Wolf administration is reading the unambiguous language of the statute to mean what it says: that after September 14eachchamber had 30 calendar days or ten legislative days, whichever is longer, to pass the resolution.
The Senate voted on the resolution on October 27, its tenth legislative day after September 14, passing it by a 32-18 margin. By the time the DEP submitted the regulation to the LRB on November 29, the House had had nineteen session days since September 14 (and 76 calendar days) and had not passed the resolution. As a result, the DEPs CO2 Budget Trading Program was deemed approved" under section 7(d) of the RRA, and the Wolf administration then took the logical next steps: it submitted the regulation to the state Attorney General for a "form and legality" review under the Commonwealth Attorneys Act, and then to the LRB.
The Attorney General has approvedas to form and legality, but House and Senate Republicans are arguingthat the RRA gives the chambers separate andconsecutive 30-calendar-days-or ten-legislative-days periods to adopt a resolution of disapproval and unfortunately, the LRB has agreed with them.There is nothing in the RRA to support this interpretation. The General Assembly must adopt the resolution within the time prescribed in section 7(d) of the RRA, and because the House did not do so on time, the resolution and the RRAs bar on promulgation have expired. Given the LRB's position, however, you might say that the resolution is undead a sort of politically reanimated zombie.
What do you do with a zombie?
According to the internet, the way to kill a zombie is to get at its brain. In this case, the brain of the zombie resolution of disapproval is the House Republicans interpretation of section 7(d) of the RRA. Getting at it will probably take a lawsuit against the LRB and the House Republicans that, or a directive to the LRB from theJoint Committee on Documents(yes, there's a Joint Committee on Documents in Pennsylvania), which oversees the LRB.
Absent such action, the LRBs refusal to publish the regulation will delay Pennsylvanias participation in RGGI by months because Senate Republicans will threaten an override of Governor Wolfs inevitable veto of the zombie resolution after it passes in the House, even though they dont have the votes. Then the LRB will presumably continue to balk until an override vote fails (or is never called). While these delay tactics may be aimed at the Governor, its ultimately the people of Pennsylvania theyll hurt. For the peoples sake, the Wolf administration should seek redress in the courts.
Read more:
Pennsylvania, RGGI, and the Case of the Zombie Resolution - NRDC (Natural Resources Defense Council)
- The Cranberries' Zombie - the story behind the incendiary song - Louder - April 22nd, 2024
- Chris Riddell on the zombie Tory government falling apart at the seams cartoon - The Guardian - April 22nd, 2024
- Zombie grave dating back 4,200 years discovered in Germany, photos show - Miami Herald - April 22nd, 2024
- Steam zombie survival game leaves early access 11 years on, and you've got one week to get it cheap - PCGamesN - April 22nd, 2024
- "Zombie" cicadas with STDs are coming to Virginia - Axios - April 22nd, 2024
- Deathtroopers is the Star Wars zombie horror game I never knew I needed - PC Gamer - April 22nd, 2024
- Zombie Army VR Reveals The Story In Latest Trailer - Bleeding Cool News - April 22nd, 2024
- Where Infected "Zombie Cicadas" In The US Will Emerge In 2024 - TheTravel - April 22nd, 2024
- Zombie anti-abortion laws are menacing American women - The Hill - April 22nd, 2024
- Joe Manganiello to Zombie It Up in Mountain Man Adaptation - Reactor - Reactor - April 22nd, 2024
- Frozen Soul Covered White Zombie and It Rules - MetalSucks - April 22nd, 2024
- Arizona's abortion ban could bring zombie laws back to life in other states - Fast Company - April 22nd, 2024
- Arizona abortion ban shows the dangers of reviving zombie laws - MSNBC - April 22nd, 2024
- Zombie fires smoldering near Canadian oil and gas wells threaten production following 2023 wildfires - WorldOil - April 22nd, 2024
- You'll Never Guess Who Doesn't Want to Repeal a Zombie Abortion Ban - The New Republic - April 22nd, 2024
- Zombie Army VR: New trailer gives a glimpse of the gruesome campaign - MIXED Reality News - April 22nd, 2024
- Zombie Tests: Is the SAT Back From the Dead? - Fair Observer - April 22nd, 2024
- How likely are you to survive a zombie apocalypse in Connecticut? You may want to travel north - Hartford Courant - April 22nd, 2024
- Missouri Reports 162 New Cases Of Deer 'Zombie' Disease In 2023 - Lake Expo - April 22nd, 2024
- Zombie Fires Pose Looming Threat to Canada's Oil and Gas Infrastructure - OilPrice.com - April 22nd, 2024
- Rob Zombie Presenting House on Haunted Hill Soundtrack on Vinyl - ComicBook.com - April 22nd, 2024
- Take on Zombie Stormtroopers In This Star Wars Fan Game - IGN - April 22nd, 2024
- The Best Zombie Game of 2023 Has a New Expansion Out Now - Esports.net News - April 22nd, 2024
- Frozen Soul Debuts Frosty Rendition of White Zombie's 'Creature of the - Knotfest - April 22nd, 2024
- 'Dawn of the Dead' at 45: A Zombie Love Affair That Never Died - The New York Times - April 12th, 2024
- Hyper-sexual 'zombie cicadas' infected with bizarre STD fungus will emerge in US - New York Post - April 12th, 2024
- Zombie malls and other retail centers getting extreme makeovers to keep up with the times - Chicago Tribune - April 12th, 2024
- 'Zombie' drug xylazine found in cannabis THC vapes in UK - BBC.com - April 12th, 2024
- Taxing health insurance: The Republican zombie that refuses to die - Roll Call - April 12th, 2024
- Fungus-infected Zombie Cicadas with hypersexuality to emerge in the US this year: Expert - Hindustan Times - April 12th, 2024
- Zombie Classic Dawn Of The Dead Coming Back to Theaters for 45th Anniversary - MetalSucks - April 12th, 2024
- E-News | 'Zombie cicadas' infected with sexually transmitted fungus expected to emerge this year in parts of US - WVU ENews - April 12th, 2024
- Deadly Zombie Sedative Penetrating The U.K.s Illicit Drugs Market - Forbes - April 12th, 2024
- Seattle Police warn that base ingredient in 'zombie drug' tranq is being sold as standalone pill - FOX 13 Seattle - April 12th, 2024
- Opinion | Today's Opinions: Haunted by zombie law and thrown into abortion time-travel - The Washington Post - The Washington Post - April 12th, 2024
- Rob Zombie Teases 'House of 1000 Corpses' Book With Rare Photos, Original Script and More! - Bloody Disgusting - April 12th, 2024
- Zombie malls getting extreme makeovers to keep up with the times - Detroit News - April 12th, 2024
- 2000s Horror Fantasy Is One Of The Most Unique Takes On The Zombie Genre - Giant Freakin Robot - April 12th, 2024
- Mysterious 'Zombie Neurons' Unlock Secrets of Learning in The Brain - ScienceAlert - April 12th, 2024
- Zombie SKUs: What They Are, How They Work & Results - JumpFly PPC Advertising News - April 12th, 2024
- Arizona Reviving Its Zombie Abortion Ban Is Trump's Doing - The Cut - April 12th, 2024
- Hyper-sexual "zombie cicadas" that are infected with sexually transmitted fungus expected to emerge this year - CBS News - April 12th, 2024
- Should we be concerned about zombie cicadas? - WGN Radio - Chicago - April 12th, 2024
- You need to play this underrated zombie shooter before it leaves Xbox Game Pass - Digital Trends - April 12th, 2024
- End the 'zombie' Comstock Act - Star Tribune - April 12th, 2024
- OPINION - Flesh-eating zombie narcotics are on our streets Britain is badly losing its war on drugs - Yahoo News UK - April 12th, 2024
- What Is Xylazine - The Flesh-Eating 'Zombie' Drug Linked To 11 Deaths in The UK? - Times Now - April 12th, 2024
- Zombie Cicadas To Emerge In Virginia: What To Know - Patch - April 12th, 2024
- What Is "Zombie Drug" Gripping The UK? - NDTV - April 12th, 2024
- OJ Simpson's Final Film Will Resurrect His Naked Gun Character - As A Zombie? - Looper - April 12th, 2024
- Flesh-eating 'zombie drug' sweeping US is linked to 11 UK deaths - The Telegraph - April 12th, 2024
- Flesh-rotting 'Zombie drug' tranq raises alarm in UK - The Times of India - April 12th, 2024
- Zombie Cicadas To Emerge In GA: What To Know - Patch - April 12th, 2024
- What was the first-ever zombie movie? - Far Out Magazine - April 12th, 2024
- Even Will Smith Couldnt Save Zombie Survival Game Undawn, Which Flopped Spectacularly - IGN - March 24th, 2024
- Rob Zombie Recommends This Surprisingly Wholesome Comedy - Dread Central - March 24th, 2024
- Army Writing and the Zombie (Noun) Apocalypse - Modern War Institute - United States Military Academy West Point - March 24th, 2024
- Fatal Fury's Mai Shiranui Is In This Zombie Survival Game For Some Reason - Time Extension - March 24th, 2024
- Should you be worried about 'zombie deer'? | College of Public Health - George Mason University - March 24th, 2024
- 'Scooby-Doo on Zombie Island' Scares Its Way to Blu-ray for the First Time This Spring - Collider - March 24th, 2024
- Rob Zombie hates my guts: GWAR's Dave 'Oderus Urungus' Brockie was a genius, and here's an interview that proves it - Louder - March 24th, 2024
- In the fight against gun violence, Rep. Frost Introduces the Destroy Zombie Guns Act - The Apopka Voice - March 24th, 2024
- Elfriede Jelinek's 'The Children of the Dead' is a historical zombie novel - The Washington Post - The Washington Post - March 24th, 2024
- Germany's Zombie Government Is Fueling the Far Right - The Atlantic - March 24th, 2024
- Zombie Survival Game Undawn Has Crashed And Burned According To A Reuters Report - MMOs.com - March 24th, 2024
- Will Smiths Zombie Game Has Been Hit Harder Than Chris Rock at the Oscars Its Astronomical Budget Was ... - imdb - March 24th, 2024
- Scooby-Doo On Zombie Island / Return to Zombie Island Blu-ray (Warner Archive Collection) - Blu-ray.com - March 24th, 2024
- Registration almost here for Dothans annual Zombie 5K Chase - WDHN - March 24th, 2024
- Zombie magic and gambling club Magic Island will come alive again this summer - Houston Chronicle - March 24th, 2024
- Undawn | The $140m zombie survival game starring Will Smith that bombed while nobody was looking - Filmstories - March 24th, 2024
- After 4 years, a cult classic zombie horror manga from Ga-Rei's creator is finally getting an official English release - Gamesradar - March 24th, 2024
- Will Smith's Zombie Game Has Been Hit Harder Than Chris Rock at the Oscars - Its Astronomical Budget Was ... - FandomWire - March 24th, 2024
- "The game literally no one knew existed": The Will Smith Zombie Survival Game is Reportedly a Big Flop and Fans Are ... - FandomWire - March 24th, 2024
- Zombie-palooza --- Get to the biggest undead music event in the latest Dead Island 2 expansion: SoLA - Gaming Trend - March 24th, 2024
- Bournemouth University medical students treat 'zombie attack' in mass training simulation - The Tab - March 24th, 2024
- Zombie car factories on the rise in China as buyers opt for EVs - Financial Times - March 16th, 2024
- Hey, Remember When Rob Zombie Was Going To Direct THE CROW 3? - FANGORIA - March 16th, 2024
- New Walking Dead Twist Shows How The Zombie Outbreak Will Finally End - Screen Rant - March 16th, 2024
- Candid conversations from death row with The Zombie Hunter - Arizona's Family - March 16th, 2024
- Zombie! The Musical - REVIEW - City Hub Sydney - March 16th, 2024
Reviewed and Recommended by Erik Baquero