For users of the nascent internet of the late-90s and early-2000s, it was a much simpler time. Text-based web design. Pixelated graphics. Dancing babies and hamsters. Remember fledgling attempts by corporations to make website tie-ins to popular productssay Coca-Colaor filmssay the 1996 Warner Brothers feature, Space Jam? Captured by the digital novelty of it all, you might have even made a first clunky website of your very own.
Fast forward to the internet of 2020, where websites of all type are increasingly traded as the digital currency of the multi-platform, social media era. Many of those early websites have lived a long life in the first two decades of the digital age, but have evolved; others have stayed the same. Famously, the original site promoting the classic duo of Michael Jordan and Bugs Bunny is still going strongan unchanged monument to mid-90s nostalgia that Rolling Stone once called The Website that Wouldnt Die. But what of the early websites that lived a short, grainy life and did dieabandoned by their creators as associated businesses and products folded, and the masses of humanity opted for the relative ease of hosting their web presence on social media platforms like Facebook and Twitter? Indeed, most of those early websites have been buried in the graveyard of digital history. But purveyors of disinformation working to game search engine optimization have exhumed some of these sites, cleaned them up, and weaponized them. This appears to now include peddlers of Russian disinformation narratives, who have reanimated moldering sites as rudimentary propaganda platforms.
Simply put: welcome to the dawn of the era of zombie disinformation websites! While digital security and disinformation experts have focused on the proliferation of Russian bot and troll social media accounts in the aftermath of the Kremlins interference in the 2016 U.S. Presidential election, zombie disinformation websites have begun to lurk among the search results for legitimate media platforms on search engines. But with so many dubious disinformation sources floating around cyberspace, what makes these sites uniquely concerning?
The potential use and reach of the zombie sites could be a possible new front for those wanting to wage low-cost information warfare. Search engines return ranked website keyword search results based on an array of site characteristics. While there is a healthy online dialogue among experts analyzing how search engines like Google or Yahoo rank results, attributes including click-through rate, key word usage, backlinks, site domain and registration age all appear to contribute to the rankings.
It would take a significant amount of organic click traffic for these sites to be regularly boosted to appear among legitimate news sites, so the fact that these sites already have years or decades of web presence in the bank means that they may be returned in searches more readily than new, home-grown disinformation sites. Thus, although these platforms appear to only receive limited click traffic, the mere fact that their specious headlines appear next to legitimate headlines may already satisfy a common objective of disinformation peddlers: creating a veneer of debate among widely agreed-upon fact-based reporting (say, an election result). The cost of reviving an older domain with a history of attributes that would help boost search rankings might be lower than traditional influence operations that rely on bot and troll armies (or advanced algorithms) to push disinformation narratives into the mainstream.
So what might these zombie sites look like? Lets consider a pair of domains: micetimes.asia and robertwoodbrokers.com. According to the Wayback Machine internet archive, micetimes started its life as far back as July 2014 as a Singapore-based business eNewspaper, where the MICE in the URL stood for the industry of Meeting, Incentive, Convention, and Exhibition. Micetimes in this form appears to have met an untimely death in late 2015, appeared briefly as a food blog in 2016, before reappearing in its current format in mid-2017. This time, the meaning of the acronym MICE was discarded in favor of a logo of an actual mouse, with the site titling itself The MiceTimes of Asia claiming to offer fresh and independent news and opinions from Singapore and Bangkok with widest news coverage and fastest delivery. The offerings of the site stand in stark contrast to this self-description, however, instead offering a distinct mix of narrativesprimarily stories featuring low quality, unintentionally comedic machine translations and articles that spark more questions than answers.
Nearly every story on the site is supposedly written by a single (apparently prolific) author named paradox who the site claims wrote the over 140,000 articles appearing on micetimes since its 2017 founding. One common story type is reporting under columns titled INCREDIBLE or The incident, which generally consist of clickbait of shocking or apocryphal tales, often including animals engaged in some level of dubious hijinks or attacking humans. Several stories tell of alleged elephant attacks on humans, including the tragic story of Amorn Morakot (Morakot Amorn) (paradox apparently isnt sure which) whose elephant killed him and attempted to hide his body. Others tell of a Vancouver-based celebrity raven who allegedly stole a knife from a crime scene after having allegedly stole the F6 key from a police laptop. (Both the elephant and raven stories, as it turns out, are convoluted retellings of true stories.)
While a few such stories might happen to have a mention of southeast Asia, the majority of stories deal with regions and topics the Kremlin might consider its near abroad. This includes a litany of alleged security incidents, often set in Eastern European nations with alarming headlines like In Warsaw, a massive explosion and including convoluted phrases like it is noted that as a result of the incident, none of the engineers were not injured. Still others have pushed anti-Western, Kremlin-friendly narratives on divisive issues like Gazproms Nord Stream 2 pipeline. On this topic, there are dozens of articles that appear to be machine translated from Russian, sometimes done so poorly that several words in the article appear to have failed software translation, instead appearing in the original Cyrillic. Others, like the articles with bellicose titles like Superpower knocked his fist on the table relative to Nord Stream 2. The world shuddered, and About gas, there are two news: good and bad include figures and images whose text are entirely in Russian.
The story of robertwoodbrokers appears to follow a similar digital pathology as micetimes, only with an even longer period between death and zombification. In this case, Wayback Machine shows that the site originated in mid-2002, and was the web platform for Robert Wood Brokers, Inc, a real, US-based business whose site at the time claimed that it provided services for the real estate needs of people living in and moving to and from the metro Atlanta area. The website was either abandoned or moved to another domain in late 2007, before remaining dormant for over a decade, according to Wayback Machine. Then in 2018, the site was reanimated, and titled RWB News News of the World with a similar distribution of automatically translated stories ranging from clickbait, to pieces with pro-Kremlin narratives like that titled Five Matters In Russia Are Far Better Than In the United States.
Both of these domains have come up near the top of web searches for a variety of European security topics, especially on energy and geopolitical issues involving Russia. There are many other domains that exhibit these similar traits: original text that has been apparently machine translated into the English language, no apparent human operator or reporter on the site, and appearing on domains that were created for entirely different purposes. Others appearing to exhibit these zombified characteristics include once legitimate web addresses for a Texas-based order of Catholic nuns, a German professional photography website, and Mumbai-based supplier of high-conductivity copper terminals. Its unclear if these sites are in fact part of a coordinated network and who may be creating them to begin with, but their commonalities are striking, sometimes carrying identical articles across several of the domains.
Also concerning: these sites have been picked up from time-to-time by legitimate news outlets, creating the potential for their false narratives to be laundered into the legitimate news stream. For example, Ukraines Kyiv Post has linked to a few micetimes articles that appear to carry fairly ordinary reporting on Ukrainian pop culture, like this 2017 repost on a creative break a Ukrainian band was planning to take that year. Social media monitoring platform CrowdTangle also shows how articles from these sites have been spread by legitimate accounts. This includes micetimes articles shared on facebook by the accounts of governments and organizations, including the Embassy of Finland in Singapore, the Slovenian Consulate in Southern Australia, and the Romanian-American Chamber of Commerce. While these were benign outcomes, where in each case the articles shared dont appear to have been targeted disinformation pieces, the incident reveals the potential for broader impact should a disinformation narrative be accidentally amplified instead.
It remains to be seen how zombie disinformation websites might be used in future information warfare scenarios, however the potential of using them in a coordinated action is troubling. Imagine if in an election season, instead of these sites sputtering out a wide mix of disparate stories in which they are only returned on certain keyword searches (as they are now), they instead were used as a swarm, all simultaneously pushing the same false story questioning, e.g., the legitimacy of an election.
Given their ability to game search engine results, they might clog news search results for certain keywords with so many similar false stories that it at least temporarily creates mass confusion. The range of situations for which such an attack could be used by an array of malign actors across the globe is broad, and the impact could be significant. It is therefore vital that the zombie phenomenon is included in digital disinformation monitoring studies so that we can better prepare in case they are one day unleashed as a tool of a broader influence campaign.
Until thenunless your Space Jam-aged site is still going strong, you might want to check that your old homepage has not become the next disinformation walking dead.
Here is the original post:
These Zombie Sites Have Been Brought Back to Life to Spew Disinformation - The Daily Beast
- This $23 emergency radio is all you need to survive the zombie (or robot) apocalypse - CNET - January 25th, 2021
- The real zombie threat as the Arctic thaws and other climate briefs - Haaretz - January 25th, 2021
- When the zombies come, I will be ready - Rochelle News Leader - January 25th, 2021
- The information warriors fighting 'robot zombie army' of coronavirus sceptics - The Guardian - January 25th, 2021
- Tips To Survive An Infinite Number Of Rounds In Black Ops: Cold Wars Zombies Mode - TheGamer - January 25th, 2021
- Yungblud and Machine Gun Kelly tease zombie film-inspired 'Acting Like That' video - NME.com - January 25th, 2021
- MGK, YUNGBLUD & Travis Barker "acting like that" l - Alternative Press - January 25th, 2021
- Rob Zombies John 5 Reveals Epic Stories While Recalling The First Time He Heard Rush - MetalCastle - January 25th, 2021
- Black Ops Cold War Zombies: 5 Boss Zombies That Need To Return (And 5 That Don't) - TheGamer - January 25th, 2021
- Why you stand a better chance of surviving a zombie apocalypse in Stoke-on-Trent than other parts of UK - Stoke-on-Trent Live - January 25th, 2021
- Call of Duty BOCW: Best Weapons and Loadouts for Zombies - EssentiallySports - January 25th, 2021
- I know just where to be when the zombie apocalypse hits - The Ogle County Life - January 22nd, 2021
- Nicollet Ave. project: a zombie streetcar and pot of Minneapolis money that nobody wants to talk about - MinnPost - January 22nd, 2021
- Zombie apocalypse map shows the best place to be in UK if the dead rose - Daily Express - January 22nd, 2021
- How The Day Of The Dead TV Show Can Best Connect To Romero's Zombie Movies - Screen Rant - January 22nd, 2021
- The Walking Dead: Does The Zombie Apocalypse Ever End? - Screen Rant - January 22nd, 2021
- Editorial: County GOP's zombie idea marches on - The Island Now - January 22nd, 2021
- Zombie law: Sec 66As curious afterlife makes the case for police independence and legal literacy - The Times of India Blog - January 22nd, 2021
- Army Of The Dead: 8 Quick Things We Know About Zack Snyders Movie - CinemaBlend - January 22nd, 2021
- Death of the 'zombie' pipeline and calling out white supremacy in politics - APTN News - January 22nd, 2021
- Survive a zombie apocalypse while you get revenge on your cheating husband! - Gamasutra - January 22nd, 2021
- The Devil's Rejects: All 4 Movies That Inspired Rob Zombie Explained - Screen Rant - January 22nd, 2021
- Lyra pays tribute to Dolores O'Riordan with beautiful cover of 'Zombie' on The Late Late Show - Irish Post - January 22nd, 2021
- Zombie cells and flu fighters - McGill Reporter - McGill Reporter - January 22nd, 2021
- Zombie film fans better equipped to deal with Covid-19 pandemic, shows study - The Financial Express - January 22nd, 2021
- Isolated in Pandemic: Is Zombie Terror a copy of #Alive? Or the opposite? Understand! - Designer Women - January 22nd, 2021
- Day of the Dead Show Confirmed To Connect To Original Movie - Screen Rant - January 22nd, 2021
- The Devil's Rejects: What Happened To The Firefly Family's Ranch Location - Screen Rant - January 22nd, 2021
- Erick the Architect of Flatbush Zombies talks 'Future Proof': [it] isn't just an EP or album title - Brooklyn Vegan - January 22nd, 2021
- NZ's "zombie" companies in trouble - New Zealand Herald - January 22nd, 2021
- Explained: How zombie films may have prepared fans for Covid-19 pandemic - The Indian Express - January 15th, 2021
- Rob Zombie and AC/DC finally find their way onto 'Jeopardy!' - WAAF - January 15th, 2021
- The 10 best and worst cities to survive a zombie apocalypse revealed - The Sun - January 15th, 2021
- Zombie Capitalism Feeding On Death And Debt Lurches Into Fascism And Default Bomb - Scoop.co.nz - January 15th, 2021
- Zendaya, zombies and asteroids: The best new films coming to Netflix in 2021 - CBC.ca - January 15th, 2021
- How The Zombie Apocalypse Prepares You For The COVID-19 Pandemic - American Council on Science and Health - January 15th, 2021
- Magic: The Gathering - Kaldheim's Necromancy Cards Are INTENSE - CBR - Comic Book Resources - January 15th, 2021
- Did Watching All Those Zombie Movies Prepare You For The Pandemic? Research Says Yes! - Forbes - January 12th, 2021
- Zombies Could Stunt the Bank Recovery - The Wall Street Journal - January 12th, 2021
- The Walking Dead: Earth's Safest City Has Mastered The Zombie Apocalypse - Screen Rant - January 12th, 2021
- US Zombie Companies Are Now $2.6 Trillion in Debt. What Does That Mean for Investors? - Motley Fool - January 12th, 2021
- Brave History January 12th, 2021 - APRIL WINE, DEEP PURPLE, ROB ZOMBIE, RAGE AGAINST THE MACHINE, LED ZEPPELIN, MERCENARY, THE BLACK CROWES, ICED... - January 12th, 2021
- How dealing with a zombie pandemic taught my students to think fast and think ethically - CEOWORLD magazine - January 12th, 2021
- Good News: Wyoming a Great Place to Survive Zombie Apocalypse - laramielive.com - January 9th, 2021
- Best Zombie Anime You Need to Stream Right Now - OtakuKart - OtakuKart - January 9th, 2021
- Zombie Apocalypse 2021? Some Twitter users think Nostradamus predicted Russian scientists will cause a plague of the undead - Monsters and Critics - January 3rd, 2021
- Prabhas to unveil trailer of upcoming Telegu film Zombie Reddy on January 2 - Republic World - January 3rd, 2021
- Discover What It Means To Be A Zombie In Adventure Game Surviving The Humans - TheGamer - December 31st, 2020
- Resident Evil Reboot Promo Art Reveals First Look At Zombie As Filming Wraps - We Got This Covered - December 31st, 2020
- Rob Zombie Appears on Cover of New Revolver Issue | Revolver - Revolver Magazine - December 31st, 2020
- Mahesh Babu and Ranveer Singh Fight off Zombies in Viral Video - News18 - December 31st, 2020
- SNP accuses UK Govt of wasting millions of taxpayer pounds on 'zombie' Scotland Office - HeraldScotland - December 31st, 2020
- Wolves could hold the key to preventing 'zombie' disease threatening US deer populations - Telegraph.co.uk - December 31st, 2020
- Rob Zombie, Ghostemane and Poppy Appear on Covers of New Revolver Issue - Revolver Magazine - December 31st, 2020
- 'Zombie' greenhouse gas lurks in permafrost beneath the Arctic Ocean - Livescience.com - December 26th, 2020
- Abadon turned into a zombie and took a bite out of Hikaru Shida - Cageside Seats - December 26th, 2020
- Millions of mink infected with coronavirus to be BURNED after 'ZOMBIE uprising' from grave - Daily Express - December 26th, 2020
- The Dead Rise Once Again With New Marvel Zombies Pops From Funko - Bleeding Cool News - December 26th, 2020
- Resident Evil Reboot Original Video Game Zombie Revealed as Filming Wraps - MovieWeb - December 26th, 2020
- Anna and the Apocalypse: Every Song Ranked From Worst To Best - Screen Rant - December 26th, 2020
- Monroe County ordered to absorb the cost related to zombie homes in towns - RochesterFirst - December 26th, 2020
- Fear The Walking Dead mystery: Who is patient zero? - Undead Walking - December 26th, 2020
- Im worried that Hikaru Shida is turning into a zombie after being bitten by Abadon - Cageside Seats - December 26th, 2020
- The zombie comedy you need to watch on HBO Max - Looper - December 26th, 2020
- Call of Duty Zombies: The 5 Best Easter Eggs (& 5 Of The Worst) - TheGamer - December 26th, 2020
- Every Type of Zombie in Back 4 Blood | Game Rant - GameRant - December 22nd, 2020
- Holidays, celebrities and the zombie apocalypse - Washington Times - December 22nd, 2020
- Army of the Dead Prequel Cast Revealed by Zack Snyder in Set Photo - Collider - December 22nd, 2020
- 'Zombie Campaigns' Continue To Accrue Money, Years After Congressional Candidates Have Stopped Running - KJZZ - December 22nd, 2020
- Don't Wait to Wind Down 'Zombie' Subsidiaries - CFO - December 22nd, 2020
- Marvel Zombies & 9 Other Timelines Where Everything Went Wrong - CBR - Comic Book Resources - December 22nd, 2020
- JOEY DIABOLIC Releases Cover Of WHITE ZOMBIE's "Creature Of The Wheel" - bravewords.com - December 22nd, 2020
- South Koreas Zombie Companies Are Scarier Than the Movies - The Wall Street Journal - December 21st, 2020
- Will the Fed Ever Stop Propping Up Zombie Companies? - Yahoo Finance - December 21st, 2020
- Gangsters are PAID taxpayer cash to hand over weapons like zombie knives - Express - December 21st, 2020
- Newly discovered fungi turn flies into zombies and devour them from the inside out - Livescience.com - December 19th, 2020
- Zombie apocalypse simulation model indicates where we should hide. - The UBJ - December 19th, 2020
- BACK 4 BLOOD First Impression: Returning To Zombies With Originality - GameTyrant - December 19th, 2020
- New Zealand's highest court find that zombies do exist in New Zealand after all - Lexology - December 19th, 2020
- Fear not the zombie companies; focus on dealing with them - The Business Times - December 19th, 2020
Reviewed and Recommended by Erik Baquero